A
lot of shows use technical advisers. It’s hard enough to write a good
autopsy scene without also having to know anatomy. Sure, writers spent
a lot of their high school nights at home alone, but we didn’t spend the time learning forensics.
While others were taking pre-med courses in college we were taking Sitcom 101 and playing poker.
So when
we’re asked to write lawyer/cop/doctor/dance shows we need a little
help. On MASH we had three technical advisers. Dr. Walt Dishell who
was our medical expert. We also had a trained nurse on the set to make
sure the actors weren’t picking up scalpels from the wrong end. (The
extras who played the patients in the operating scenes used their own
organs, by the way. There were no guts-doubles.)
Additionally,
we had a military adviser. When you hear Radar rattle off a list of
incomprehensible army directives some are actually legit. And who
needs to make up insane military procedures when all you have to do is
use the real thing?
A Colonel from the Public Information Office
of the army was assigned to us. When we first spoke to him he was very
by-the-book, very wary of what we show business personnel
were going to do with the information he was asked to provide. He also
was new to the assignment, having only recently been transferred to Los
Angeles. He had been overseas for two years.
We would ask him a
simple question. He would call back with a long excruciatingly
detailed answer that would include no less than five directives, four
regulations, and seven procedures.
Now flash forward a year.
We
call him for clarification on where death certificates were sent and he
says, “Yeah yeah, sweetie, I’ll get to that. But first, I’ve got a
great idea for a pilot. Okay, now picture this: establishing shot…”
And he goes on to describe this stupefying idea. And all the while I'm
thinking:
Sweetie? Establishing shot??
From
then on we called him very rarely. Making stuff up was better than
hearing his latest movie/pilot/mini series idea. And how do you
complain to his superiors that we wanted a different adviser because
this highly decorated war hero Colonel had gone too Hollywood?
So
the next time you see a TV doctor or lawyer spouting authentic dialog
just know there is a technical adviser somewhere, who spent years in law
school or medical school, making an appointment for a Botox treatment.
My father, who is a retired radiologist, was always amused back in the '60s when he would see upside down X-Rays in doctor's offices on television.
ReplyDeleteThings have advanced a lot since then.
Great post Ken.
ReplyDeleteI recall doing some pre planning for a movie.
And they had lots of technical advisers for the script.
They can improve things.
Telly
I haven't consulted since LA Law and my wrinkles could sure use a touch-up.
ReplyDeleteLol, okay, that anecdote about the Colonel "going Hollywood" was hilarious!
ReplyDeleteSometimes it all works out for the best though--remember, George Kennedy started out as the technical adviser on The Phil Silvers Show.
ReplyDeleteI was so pleased when I was working on a John Wells Production in New York City and got to meet the Emergency Doctor who was the technical advisor of ER. (We had out own advisors but this Doc was a god to me.)
ReplyDeleteI wonder how much technical advice gets ignored because it would wreck the story or otherwise get in the way. Stephen Ambrose was technical advisor on SAVING PRIVATE RYAN and was shown a rough cut and asked what he thought. "Well, for a start, Tom Hanks is too old," he said. "The average age of an infantry captain in World War II was 23." After a silence, someone said, "What else?" They wanted to be sure they were using the correct rifles, uniform badges, etc. Recasting the movie was not about to happen.
ReplyDeleteAlways ask the experts first, as you clearly did on MASH.
I'm reminded of Alan Alda's story of how he became ill in South America and had to have surgery, and when the doctor told him what the problem was, Alda identified the procedure and the doctor wondered if he was working on a colleague! Thanks, Dr. Dishell!
ReplyDeleteThat's funny! Got all full of himself, he's "working in the biz" now, don't you know, haha
ReplyDeleteFriday Question
ReplyDeleteWhere do you stand on the concept of holograms of dead singers in concert with live bands? There's going to be a concert tour in which a hologram of Whitney Houston will appear on stage while playback of her vocals are backed up by a live band. I think the whole thing is grotesque and tasteless, and I question the intelligence of anyone paying to watch such a travesty.
I wonder if some shows realize they need one. I've had a thread going on my FB feed about how Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist amounts to a handbook of how *not* to be a manager in a software development company. Also, the lead's not really coming across as a software developer period, and a lot of the "developer talk" is just wrong. As one person put it, now he knows how his lawyer friends felt about .
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand, there is a place in the Ferry Building that sells Cheesequakes, so they got that right.
[Available as a consultant in these areas at reasonable rates, down to the level of pointing out that any developer who creates a software spelling system for their paralyzed with an ALS-like disease father to communicate is going to drop at least three Stephen Hawking references : -)).]
My wife, an ex-nurse, loves to watch medical shows just to pick holes - "Oh, we'd never do that", "Oh, that is so wrong" - so I try to watch anything computer related, to do the same. My favourite is Scotty in Star Trek IV, who starts off talking to the mouse of a Mac SE ("Oh, computer!"), and then starts hammering away on the keyboard of the totally graphical Mac interface.
ReplyDeleteI have no life, no friends...
I just watched the episode "Point of View". Can you shed any light on how logisticly that show was shot.
ReplyDeleteImagine being the medical advisor on House, M.D. "Okay, yes, it could be A but almost kill the patient, and then it could be B but they almost kill the patient, and then there's C, which only a genius could figure out."
ReplyDeleteI say this as someone who very much enjoyed the early seasons.
The other extreme would be Bill Clark, the former NYPD detective who started out as the technical adviser on NYPD Blue but who was soon bumped up to writer/producer. He ended up with 199 story credits.
ReplyDelete@Loosehead. Very sorry you have no friends, but I'll remember your comment if I watch Star Trek IV again and sniker at Scotty a little in your honor. :)
ReplyDeleteSean
>Making stuff up was better than hearing his latest movie/pilot/mini series idea.
ReplyDeleteThanks for explaining the making of Suits.
I recall an interview with the cast of Law and Order, giving credit to their technical advisers (detectives, lawyers, etc.). One thing that stood out was that the dark humor and snide comments in the opening scenes (especially Lenny Briscoe's dialogue) was based on how detectives actually talked, using humor to cope with the ugliness of what they were dealing with.
ReplyDeleteThe Martian "used" a technical advisor - a heavy-hitter at NASA. They even "bragged" on NPR about being faithful to tech/scientific/technological veracity - so I looked forward to a rare hard-SF film.
ReplyDeleteIt was mostly kinda OK (to this "science kid") but their were some "howlers" - not the least of which was a brief cut to solar panels (!) The mass-penalty for PV-panel is large - even in 2040, since one can never get better than 100% efficiency.