After the yearlong derby, here were my favorites:
Mayim, David Faber (I didn’t even know who he was before), Joe Buck (made the game and the show really fun… and he’s my podcast guest this week. Check it out), Robin Roberts, Anderson Cooper, Ken Jennings, Buzzy Cohen, and Mike Richards.
I don’t know what the excitement was about for Aaron Rogers (exceeding low expectations is not the same as “good”), and LeVar Burton (not living up to high expectations despite the hype) .
Bringing up the rear were Dr. Oz and Bill Whittaker.
The rest were all just sort of in the middle. Various shades of meh.
It should be duly noted that although Mike Richards is the Executive Producer of JEOPARDY, this was not his call. This was the head honchos of Sony. So it’s not like he just chose himself. In fact, it was his job to train the other hosts and ensure they did the best job they could. Almost to a person they have praise for Richards in how supportive he was. He could have sabotaged them, but he didn’t. And in this town...
Mike Richards also did an excellent job during his two-week stint.
One of the requirements was that JEOPARDY be the person’s primary gig. That let out any of the candidates who already had sweet TV gigs. Was Anderson Cooper or Dr. Gupta going to leave CNN? Was Robin Roberts going to leave ABC or Savannah Guthrie NBC? Even Mayim Bialik. Hosting part-time allows her to continue her acting career. For the syndicated show she would have to give up acting — tough to do when she’s currently starring in a sitcom that just got picked up for a second season.
And finally, this: Whenever I was show runner and we had a part for an athlete or a comedian, our philosophy was always “hire the actor.” Yes, he may not be as authentic an athlete or comedian but he knows the ropes. He knows how to commit to a character, how to deliver the jokes, how to hit marks and satisfy other technical requirements. We never went wrong “hiring the actor.” I think this is what Sony did. Mike Richards knows how to host game shows. He doesn’t need tutoring. Yes, he may be a somewhat safe choice, but here’s the thing: Whoever they picked there would be people outraged because he/she wasn’t their favorite or they hated him/her. That’s the problem with on-air auditions. You see the options. If Mike Richards had been named permanent host immediately following Alex Trebek’s death it would take the audience a little time to warm to him and then he would just be accepted as the new host. Very few people would stop watching JEOPARDY. The year-long derby created unreasonable expectations. But at the end of the day, this is the guy who got the job, you can grumble for a few months, and eventually you’re just watching JEOPARDY and this happens to be the guy reading the clues.
I wish Mike Richards the best. He deserved it as much as anybody and I think he’ll do a great job. Would anyone do it better? What difference does it make? They don’t have the job and Mike does.
And Mayim Bialik will shine as well. For her I couldn't be happier. She'll have no problem pronouncing those Yiddish clues.



























